Understanding the Dalai Lama’s Retirement Statement

On Tuesday, November 30, 2010, in Dalai Lama, Tibetan Politics, by Bhuchung K. Tsering

The recent media statements by the Dalai Lama about his desire to announce complete retirement has create a buzz among Tibet watchers at all levels. I have no doubt that the Chinese government, primarily, and all concerned governments are studying the implication of such a development. China is already testing the waters by having “scholars” comment on the statement. The Chinese seem to be closely following the development, as they should be, and have publicly outlined the chronology of the Dalai Lama’s statements relating to his retirement.

At the onset, when the Dalai Lama talks about “retirement” it should not be taken in the way a conventional politician or international figure retires from public life. The Dalai Lama’s latest statement has to be understood in the context of his description of the historical responsibility of the institution and how it has changed in recent years. As he explains it, historically, the Dalai Lamas have been both the spiritual and temporal leader of Tibet. While the temporal leadership was limited to the Tibetan people, the spiritual authority expands to almost all followers of Tibetan Buddhism who regard him as the manifestation of the Bodhisattva of Compassion. His spiritual followers have traditionally been the Tibetans, the Buddhists along the Himalayan region, as well as the Buddhists in Mongolia and the Russian republics of Buryatia, Kalmykia and Tuva (as I write this the Dalai Lama is giving teachings to several hundred Buddhists from these places in the  Russian Federation who have gathered in Dharamsala). In the post 1959 period there are several thousand followers of Tibetan Buddhism throughout the world who also revere him as a spiritual leader.

In 2001, following the establishment of the system of the directly elected positions of the Kalon Tripa, the Chairman of the Tibetan Cabinet and the de facto head of the Central Tibetan Administration, much of the political authority has been delegated to it. The Dalai Lama has said that since then he has more or less ceased being the temporal leader.

Therefore, his latest statement, to me, is a step towards making this transformation in the age-old responsibilities of the institution of the Dalai Lama more formal. His Holiness has talked about wanting to discuss this matter with the Tibetan Parliament in Exile, which is the highest decision making authority in the Tibetan administration system in exile. The parliament is scheduled to have its next session in March 2011.

Even if the Dalai Lama decides on his retirement, he has said he will continue to be active in the public domain, primarily to continue his work towards the promotion of human values and religious harmony.

On the broader issue of the Dalai Lama commanding the loyalty and trust of the Tibetan people, particularly those in Tibet, I do not foresee any changes in the future. The Dalai Lama will continue to be regarded by the Tibetan people as their free spokesman, irrespective of the changes that take place in his political role in exile. His role as the moral authority on the Tibetan issue will not diminish. As one Chinese Government scholar has understood it, the Dalai Lama, in a sense, cannot retire. He will continue to be a force to reckon with.

Having said that, there will be an impact in the Tibetan political movement in exile. First of all, this will be a challenge that the new Kalon Tripa will have to face in 2011 i.e. if the Dalai Lama’s discussions with the Tibetan Parliament ends up with his making that formal decision of retirement. The individual will have to assume more responsibility, be more decisive and not to be seen pushing issues back into the Dalai Lama’s hands. Also the Tibetan administrative system in exile, including the various offices connected with the Dalai Lama, will have to undergo the necessary repositioning under such a development.

The Tibetan people in exile will also have to undergo a paradigm shift in their thinking and adapt to this new reality. The Dalai Lama has been making efforts to shake off the Tibetan people’s over dependence on him and this is one more step towards that objective. Then there have also been some individuals who have said that the absence of the Dalai Lama from the governmental system would not altogether be a bad thing for the Tibetan struggle. The Dalai Lama’s statement will now be a challenge to these individuals to rise to the occasion and play a responsible role in preparing Tibetan society for such a development. This will be the time for these people to walk the talk.

Internationally, governments should now find it easier to have a simple, transparent and clear position towards the Dalai Lama than in the past.  To date, several governments have tried to overcome the perception of being seen as dealing with Dalai Lama the political leader by formally regarding him as a spiritual leader only. Now that the Dalai Lama is thinking of divesting himself of any semblance of a formal political position, unless politics kick in governments should find it easier to have a formal relationship with him as an eminent religious leaders.

Above all, the statement will have implication on how the Chinese leadership perceives the Dalai Lama. His voluntary relinquishing of all formal political authority will be a challenge to any political agenda they may have about the institution. They will be caught in a Catch 22 situation. They may not be wanting the Dalai Lama to have any political influence over the Tibetan people but his announcement will also be something that they may not be desiring.

The Dalai Lama’s statement about his complete retirement thus has more than meets the eye, and we will wait to see how things develop in the coming months.

14 Responses to “Understanding the Dalai Lama’s Retirement Statement”

  1. Jeff Stockwell says:

    Things change, hopefully for the better. China’s leadership change is even bigger than the Dalia Lama’s retirement. Now is the time for the different camps to join forces. The mainlanders who want a more just society, the Tibetan’s and other minority groups, the Tiwanese, the exiled leadership, and everybody else who wants a fair international community.

  2. jolie diane says:

    Brilliant. What if we All retired from the political system(s) so we could truly Unite as One Human Family and follow our highest spiritual path(s)? Peace, Human Values, and Spiritual Harmony seem like the most relevant use of One’s time. If We stop giving energy to politics, will politics stop giving energy to us?

    Infinite Love and Gratitude to HH and All – May we follow his beautiful example of Love, Wisdom and Compassion in ACTION.

  3. Masja Bunicich says:

    I am no politician. As I observe it the tibetan government is taking steps into a new development. The Kalon tripa may be become more important in the future. The Dalai Lama was always the head of the state also to the tibetans. The Dalai Lama handed over some of his power in 1990 to the tibetan kashag. His intentions are democratic as far as I can see. However the world sees him as the spiritual and political leader and the main spokesman. That must be a difficult role for him. The distinction between a spiritual leader and a political leader must be clear in my point of view. As I understand the Dalai Lama he more wants for himself a spiritual role. He wants to promote human values and religious harmony. That is a more spiritual role and I underline that. My comment was a personal comment and not political.

  4. Masja Bunicich says:

    De Dalai Lama mogelijk in ruste
    Komt tijd komt raad
    De wereld kuste
    Een man van wereldformaat
    Een welverdiende pensionering
    Na zoveel jaren
    Een klein babbeltje met Tsering
    Dat U nog meer wijsheid mag vergaren
    Dalai Lama neem de tijd
    Om nog dieper te reflecteren op het leven
    En laat de strijd
    Door anderen beleven
    Moge de Boeddha’s U beschermen
    In een veilige omgeving
    En zich over U ontfermen
    In een innige beleving!

    Masja Bunicich

  5. katia di bernardini says:

    i do think
    that we are going to miss this spiritual leader

  6. lhamo tsering says:

    Your writing is always interesting and elaborative…thanks Bhuchung la.

    For us Tibetan deep in our heart His Holiness the Dalai Lama, is, will, always remain supreme head and without any doubt 100% devotion…. My prayers for His Long life, long live His Holiness The Dalai Lama

  7. Tenzin Rangzen says:

    I always admire the decision of His Holiness because his idea for retirement is challenges to Communist China baseless allegation and making our Democratic in more advance. His Holiness is always leader in the heart of entire Tibetans even after his retirement and we should support his decision. so let make His Holiness as world leader and will make better impact.

  8. Piero Cerri says:

    Once more the Dalai Lama shows his wisdom. Of course retirement should not be understood in the traditional way in which is meant in the west. His retirement is a political statement for the advance of a free democratic modern Tibet. A constitunional style monarchy could be an interesting development.

  9. གོང་དཀར་ངག་་རྣམ། says:

    ངས་ཁོང་གིས་བགྲེས་ཡོལ་གྱི་བཀའ་མོལ་གནང་དུས་ང་ཚོར་ཡིད་ཆེས་དང་རེ་བ་ཞིག་ཡོད་པའི་ཐོག་ནས་གནང་གི་ཡོད་པའི་ཚོར་སྣང་ཤུགས་ཆེ་ཡོད་ལ།
    དེ་དག་ལས་ང་ཚོས་ད་ལྟ་ནས་སེམས་ནང་ཉར་དགོས་པའི་བཀའ་མོལ་ཞིག་ནི་་་་་་་་་་་་ང་ཡོད་ཀྱང་མེད་པ་ལྟ་བུར་འོས་འགན་ཁྱེར་དགོས་་་་་་་་་་་་་་་ཞེས་པ་འདི་ཡིན་སྙམ་གྱི་ཡོད།
    བྱས་ཙང་ཚང་མས་འདི་སེམས་ལ་ཉར་དགོས་ཀྱི་འདུག

  10. Dhardon Sharling says:

    Thank you Buchung K Tsering la for providing us with a deeper insight into His Holiness’s ‘retirement statement’ doing its hyped rounds in the media circuit.The Tibetans inside and outside of Tibet have time and again reaffirmed their supreme faith in His Holiness’s indomitable leadership and albeit His Holiness has the purest intention to nudge the Tibetans off from the wall of dependency, but it is foreseeable that the Tibetan people will once again hail His Holiness as the undisputed temporal leader and I for one will be a front-runner in this pursuit.

  11. Antony Wright says:

    HH Dalai Lama’s spiritual authority in the world will, if anything, be enhanced by his renunciation of political authority.

    In a sense his spiritual authority will become irresistible because there will be nothing to resist.

    Om Mani Padme Hum

  12. I agree with babara frake. Meeting HHDL was the best moment in my life. I wish to serve his devotion to compassion in action. “This is the most courageous man since Jesus. His understanding of the depth and breadth of human existence is beyond what most of us can imagine.He and the Tibetan people should be entitled to our help and support, to preserve the utmost human reach to the height of spiritual knowledge and existence.
    Even by altitude, they are close to heaven, and it’s for a reason!”

  13. Sadhya van Os says:

    It feels like a very good and intelligent decision and in my view will make his pledge for spiritual freedom for his people in Tibet more explicitely clear. Yes, let us see what excuse the Chinese come up with now that His Holiness is taking the wind out of their vicious sails.
    Love Sadhya

  14. This is the most courageous man since Jesus. His understanding of the depth and breadth of human existence is beyond what most of us can imagine.
    He and the Tibetan people should be entitled to our help and support, to preserve the utmost human reach to the height of spiritual knowledge and existence.
    Even by altitude, they are close to heaven, and it’s for a reason!

Leave a Reply